Unreal Cities

 

Unreal Cities

 

For a political thinker, Eric Voegelin is decidedly atypical. He diagnoses individuals and political movements by looking at them through the most refined lenses attainable: the lens of rationality and the lens of spirituality. For Voegelin, pathological developments in persons or societies are traceable to the absence of these two higher elements: the rationality that we have inherited from Greece and Rome and the spirituality that is the gift of Biblical Israel.

By mid-nineteenth century (as he writes in the final chapter of Hitler and the Germans), both of these higher strata were crumbling – at least among those deemed the most advanced thinkers. Even before Darwin, the science-minded were starting to speculate about the origins of the human species in terms of an evolution from earlier, more primitive species. It followed that our nobler aspirations had no natural basis. So they could be kept going – by ignorance or else some kind of bootstrapping anyway – without foundation other than our own will or imagination.

Voegelin cites four nineteenth-century thinkers who had an outsized influence and embodied what I’m calling this strategy of “anyway”: Karl Marx, Friedrich Nietzsche, Sigmund Freud and Max Weber. The last, Weber, is the only one whom Voegelin respects as a thinker who fully faced what he took to be a meaningless reality but tried to be constructive nonetheless. But the other three, Marx, Nietzsche and Freud, Voegelin describes as having constructed pseudo-solutions to the problem all three shared: hopelessness. 

About Freud’s pseudo-solution, I’ve recently learned a little more – namely that the whole edifice was built on sand more crumbling than I’d imagined. The Freud back story is told in Trauma and Recovery by Judith L. Herman, MD. Here’s the gist. Two researchers, Freud in Vienna and French neurologist Jean-Martin Charcot, with his follower Pierre Janet, in Paris, were (on separate tracks) investigating the phenomenon of “hysteria” in women. These investigators were discovering something we now take for granted: hysteria was a condition caused by suppressed memories of trauma. If the memories could be “recovered and put into words,” the patient’s symptoms would abate and recovery was possible (p. 17).

So far, so good. Sounds like a happy story of scientific research leading to improvement – finding a cure – for a human problem. It turned out that Freud was more willing than even Charcot to listen to the women patients.

“What he heard was appalling. Repeatedly his patients told him of sexual assault, abuse and incest.” In “The Aetiology of Hysteria,” published in 1896, Freud reported the results of 18 case studies. He believed he had definitively solved the problem of neuropathology. In every case, he found that there had been “premature sexual experience, occurrences which belong to the earliest years of childhood” (p. 18).

We think of women’s liberation in terms of securing the right to vote, or to initiate divorce, and similar advances in the adult exercise of freedom. We don’t necessarily think of the right to protection in childhood – or of the unliberated woman as vulnerable to childhood molestation. But apparently, that was part of the tragic (if unofficial) story of pre-feminist womanhood. Not in every family of course. But more than was acknowledged. 

It seems the young Freud was willing to follow the evidence where it lay. That is, he did that until – facing the fact such a view would place serious obstacles to a career in Vienna – “Freud stopped listening to his patients.” Instead, “Freud created psychoanalysis”! His theory accomplished the discrediting of his women patients. Now, “without offering any clinical documentation of false complaints, in his new theory, Freud had concluded that his hysterical patients’ accounts of childhood sexual abuse were untrue: ‘I was at last obliged to recognize that these scenes of seduction had never taken place, and that they were only fantasies which my patients had made up’” (p. 20). 

And so the Freudian “unconscious” was born. It became the repository, the holding area, in which real-life abuses were silenced and replaced by hypothetical constructs: the Electra and Oedipus complexes. Under these hypotheses, Freud found patients who – he alleged – unconsciously wanted to kill their same-sex parents in order to enjoy sexual access to their opposite-sex parents.

In my youth, in New York, all the clever people (and unhappily I include myself) were in psychoanalysis! Which meant that we/they were paying serious money to be diagnosed as suffering from a condition that wasn’t there! A condition that had come into social currency as the cover story fabricated by Freud to mask the childhood recollections of his actual patients. 

It didn’t mean that our therapists were giving us no help at all. But whatever help they gave would depend on their individual talents, their sensitivity and insight – not the theory that supposedly rendered their contributions “scientific”!

*. *. *

What about the two other nineteenth-century theoreticians whom Voegelin cites as spinning out their theories to fill the vacuum left by the denial of reason and spirit? I mean Marx and Nietzsche. What about them?

Marx offers one of the century’s “world-immanent apocalypses of history” to which “revolutionary activism belong[s] essentially.” In Nietzsche, “[t]he denial of the spirit produces the suffering of Godforsakenness. … The suffering from the meaninglessness of a Godforsaken existence leads to outbreaks of concupiscent fantasy, to the grotesque creation of a ‘new man’ – of Marx’s and Nietzsche’s supermen”(p. 262f).

Let’s break it down a little bit. What exactly is wrong with the consoling fantasy of a superman? Well, Nietzsche’s postulated superman stands on a terrain “beyond good and evil.” And, in real life, there is no such terrain. If you imagine that you’re beyond good and evil, then – when push comes to shove and you’re faced with a real-life choice you can’t dodge – you’ll be more likely to choose evil. It takes time – practice and discipline – to detect evil and to resist it. The devotee of Nietzsche is unlikely to have put in that time.

As for the various editions of Marxism, his followers have provided themselves with a capacious cover story. Any harm they might want to do – any responsibility they might like to shirk – can be rationalized by an appeal to the inner springs of “history.” 

I recall one afternoon at the café du Tournon in Paris, and expatriate writer Richard Wright quoting to me these lines that he credited to Albert Camus:

I refuse to kill my brother

for an unreal city in the future.

 

 

About Abigail

Abigail Rosenthal is Professor Emerita of Philosophy, Brooklyn College of CUNY. She is the author of A Good Look at Evil, a Pulitzer Prize nominee, now available in an expanded, revised second edition and as an audiobook. Its thesis is that good people try to live out their stories while evil people aim to mess up good people’s stories. Her latest book, Confessions of a Young Philosopher, illustrated by Caroline Church, explores the thesis in her own life. She writes a weekly column for her blog, “Dear Abbie: The Non-Advice Column” (www.dearabbie-nonadvice.com) where she explains why human lives are in fact quite interesting. She’s the editor of the posthumously published Consolations of Philosophy: Hobbes’s Secret; Spinoza’s Way by Henry M. Rosenthal, her father. Some of her articles can be accessed at https://brooklyn-cuny.academia.edu/AbigailMartin . She is married to Jerry L. Martin, also a philosopher. They live in Bucks County, Pennsylvania.
This entry was posted in Absolute Freedom and Terror, absurdism, academe, action, afterlife, agnosticism, alienation, American politics, anthropology, anti-semitism, appreciation, art, art of living, atheism, authenticity, autonomy, bad faith, beauty, Bible, Biblical Archeology, Biblical God, bigotry, book reviews, books, bureaucracy, childhood, chivalry, Christianity, cities, class, Confessions of a Young Philosopher, conformism, contemplation, contradictions, cool, courage, courtship, cults, cultural politics, culture, desire, Desire and Authenticity, dialectic, eighteenth century, erotic life, eternity, ethics, ethnicity, evil, existentialism, exploitation, faith, fashion, fatherhood, female power, femininity, feminism, filial piety, films, freedom, friendship, gender balance, glitterati, Gnosticism, guilt and innocence, health, Hegel, hegemony, heroes, hidden God, hierarchy, history, history of ideas, id, idealism, ideality, identity, ideology, idolatry, immorality, immortality, Industrial Revolution, institutional power, Jesus, Jews, journalism, Judaism, law, legal responsibility, life and death struggle, literature, love, male power, Married Philosophers Discuss Confessions, martyrdom, masculinity, master, master/slave relation, medieval, memoir, memory, Messianic Age, mind control, modern women, modernism, moral action, moral evaluation, moral psychology, morality, mortality, mortality vs immortality, motherhood, mysticism, Nihilism, nineteenth-century, non-violence, novels, ontology, oppression, pacifism, past and future, peace, Phenomenology of the Mind, philosophy, poetry, political, political movements, politics, politics of ideas, postmodernism, power, power games, presence, promissory notes, propaganda, psychology, public facade, public intellectual, race, racism, radicalism, reading, reductionism, relationships, religion, remembrance, Renaissance, repairing the culture, roles, romance, romantic love, romanticism, science, scientism, secular, seduction, self-deception, seventeenth century, sex appeal, sexuality, slave, social climbing, social construction, social conventions, social ranking, sociobiology, spiritual journey, spiritual not religious, spirituality, status, status of women, suffering, Suicide, terror, terrorism, the examined life, the problematic of men, the problematic of woman, the profane, the sacred, theism, theology, time, Trauma, Truth, TV, twentieth century, twenty-first century, Utopia, victimhood, victims, violence, war, work, writing, Zeitgeist and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply